This site has limited support for your browser. We recommend switching to Edge, Chrome, Safari, or Firefox.

Order by 11:45pm Tue & Thu for next delivery (aest)

Use coupon code BUBS10 for 10% off your first order.

Cart 0

Congratulations! Your order qualifies for free shipping You are $175 away from free shipping.
Sorry, looks like we don't have enough of this product.

Pair with
Subtotal Free

View cart
Shipping, taxes, and discount codes are calculated at checkout

Your Cart is Empty

Self-Feeding vs Spoon Feeding: Navigating the Messy Adventure of Starting Solids

Self-Feeding vs Spoon Feeding: Navigating the Messy Adventure of Starting Solids

Starting solids with your baby can be a roller coaster experience, and a messy one at that! And just when you thought it couldn’t get messier, you hear that your baby should be self-feeding! But what exactly does self-feeding entail? And is it really any better than spoon feeding your baby yourself? Let’s take a deep dive into the messy adventure of starting solids, and explore who should be in charge of the spoon!


What exactly is self-feeding?

Self-feeding is a weaning method where you let your baby take the lead (and the spoon!). Instead of feeding bub yourself, self-feeding involves your baby bringing food to their own mouth to eat.


Why should babies feed themselves?

Learning to feed themself is a really important stage in your baby’s development and here are a few of the reasons why:

  • It teaches them independence. We know the thought of your baby not needing you for every little thing can be a real tear jerker, but once they start to learn how to feed themself, it’s just the beginning of everything else they’ll learn to do on their own.
  • It’s a skill they’ll need for life, so why not start them off early!
  • Teaching your baby to feed themself is a great way to practise their fine motor skills. Over the months, you’ll watch them progress from using their entire fist (or the palmar grip) to bring food to their mouth, to perfecting their pincer grip to pick up smaller foods with their fingers.
  • As messy as it can be, all the touching, squeezing and dropping of food teaches them so much about different foods, textures, temperatures and smells.

What to expect with self-feeding:

Here are some of the signs that your baby may be ready for this next step:

  • They reach out for the spoon when you are feeding them
  • They are starting to reach for or grab food off their plate (or yours!)
  • They may be grabbing other objects or toys and bringing it to their mouth

When your baby begins to show these signs, it’s best to give them as many opportunities as you can to allow them to practise these skills. You can let them practise during meal times by giving them a spoon to play with.


To your baby, feeding themself can be a tricky concept that will probably take a while to perfect. As frustrating and messy as it can get, it’s important to encourage bub to keep trying time and time again. Remember, your baby is in charge of self-feeding, so let them take their time to master this skill.


How do I teach my baby to self-feed?

Start off small! To first expose your baby to the concept of self-feeding, place some soft finger foods in their reach/ on their high chair. These could be something like:

  • Cooked strips of chicken or meat
  • Spears of soft ripe bananas, avocado or kiwi fruit
  • Soft, cooked sweet potato, carrot or zucchini spears
  • Pieces of soft, cooked, skinless apple or pear

You may find that bub may only play with the food the first few times you put it out in front of them- that’s totally fine! While we know you’d probably much rather it in their mouth, your baby will learn so much about different foods and textures just from playing with it.


Most babies won’t be able to perfect their pincer grip or confidently use a spoon properly until they are about 18 months old. Here are some ways to encourage them to start using one and practice perfecting their skill:

  • Eat meals together. Eating in front of your baby is a great way to model to them how to use utensils. (Baby see, baby do)
  • Start with silicone utensils that have a good comfortable grip. These will be easier for your baby to hold until they progress to metal utensils when their skills improve. You can purchase your baby’s first utensil set here: https://www.nourishingbubs.com/collections/feeding-accessories
  • While you spoon feed your baby, give them another spoon to hold. You can even do this before introducing self-feeding. This will give them time to practise gripping and holding utensils.
  • Load the food onto the spoon/fork for your baby and then give it to them to practise bringing it up to their mouth on their own. This takes the finer, more skillful part out of the task to start them off in those earlier stages.

Some tips to help you through this messy time

Always supervise- As your baby begins to eat more independently, it’s important you continue to monitor their mealtimes very closely. Make sure your child is seated upright and not playing or crawling around on the floor. It’s also important to monitor their tolerance to new textures as you introduce them.


Know the difference between choking and gagging- Gagging is a very common and actually normal occurrence when your baby starts to try new foods. Gagging is your baby’s defence against choking and can often happen when your baby has too much food in their mouth or hasn’t chewed their food enough. While your baby may be scared and throw you into panic mode, the gag reflex will help bring the food back to the front of the mouth so your baby can chew it more efficiently. On the other hand, choking is when the airway is blocked, causing your baby to stop breathing. Your baby may go silent or flail their arms- this requires immediate action.


Prepare for the mess- There will be a lot of it! Here are some ways to deal with the mess:

  • Embrace it! We know it’s easier said than done, but just remember, this is only one stage of their life! They won’t be throwing food on the floor forever (hopefully…)
  • Invest in some quality bibs or smocks for your baby to wear at each mealtime. Nourishing Bubs have a range to cover you all the way from 0 months to 4 years! You can purchase yours here: https://www.nourishingbubs.com/collections/feeding-accessories
  • Place a drop sheet or an old towel under the highchair or table to catch any of the mess that lands on the floor.
  • Offer your baby finger foods that will be easier for them to pick up and chew based on the stage they are at. For example, coating banana or avocado spears in some ground nuts or sesame seeds can help your baby grip onto them easier.
  • If you have a safe flat surface, set up an eating spot outside.

Praise the small wins, and ignore the big throws- We know it can be super frustrating to be constantly picking up food off the floor that you wished ended up in bub’s mouth. One way to deal with your baby dropping or throwing food on the floor is to simply ignore it. If you constantly react when food lands on the floor, they may think it’s a game and continue to do it. Instead, calmly pick up the food without a fuss or leave the food on the floor until the meal is over so you only have one clean up to do.

On the other hand, it’s really important to praise your baby on all their little achievements as they begin to feed themself. They’ll need this positive encouragement to keep trying and improving.


Be patient- Your baby is in charge when it comes to self-feeding, so let them practise and only step in to assist when they need help. Try not to rush them to finish their meals- the skill of self feeding is also teaching your baby to listen to their hunger cues at the same time (a really really important skill you’ll want them to carry through their life).


Should I still spoon feed my baby?

Spoon feeding is a traditional weaning method that simply means you use a spoon to put food in your baby’s mouth. This is most common when using purees to start your baby’s solids journey, instead of baby led weaning.


Of course there are positives to this approach:

  • It allows Mum/Dad to relatively be in control (in the uncontrollable world of raising a baby, this can feel like a big win!)
  • It tends to make less of a mess; or more so, the mess is more contained (we know you’ll take another slight win Mumma/Dadda)
  • You can control more of what goes into their mouth, as opposed to landing on the floor (which means less cleaning for you- another win!)

When or how should I spoon feed my baby?

Spoon feeding can still come in handy in the early stages of teaching your baby how to feed themself. When your baby is first exploring how to bring food to their own mouth and is mainly just playing with their food, spoon feeding may be the only way to actually get some food (and nutrients) into their mouth.


Learning how to handle a spoon to bring food to their own mouth is a long process that can take months! So bub will still need your help for a while with certain foods like yoghurt and cereal.


When spoon feeding your baby, there’s a few techniques to remember to ensure your baby has a positive eating experience:

  • Keep the spoon flat rather than tilting it up in bub’s mouth. This will help bub practise getting food off the spoon themself with the correct technique.
  • Only remove the spoon from bub’s mouth when they are ready. Again this will give your baby control of removing the food from the spoon.
  • Don’t overload the spoon. Giving your baby too much food at once can trigger a gag reflex.
  • If your baby doesn’t open their mouth for the spoon, don’t try to force their mouth open. This is another way that your baby is tuning into their hunger cues, listen to it.
  • Try not to constantly clean their face while they are eating. Imagine if someone did this to you- it would be quite irritating right? It may put them off their meal and make them stop eating.

Whether you are spoon feeding or teaching your baby to self-feed, the main goal is to cultivate a safe and enjoyable eating experience without the stress. As bub takes the lead, your role is to be a friendly supporter; assisting their skill development and modelling safe eating techniques. So while this may be a very messy and slightly stressful journey, remember that each meal time is an opportunity for your baby to develop and perfect new skills they’ll use for the rest of their life!